We’ve gained valuable experience in designing our first Passive House in Middlebury. We’re putting that experience to good use with our second Passive House, this time in Lincoln, VT. Passive House #2 is the spiritual twin of #1, but with a couple key differences.
First, most obviously, is the larger lot. The Middlebury site is a snug fit thanks to several competing setbacks, so the extra breathing room on a large site allows much more flexibility in placing the house. The house was placed on the north side of a clearing, so no trees had to be removed to get the best use of solar gain.
Second is the foundation structure. The dramatic topography of the Middlebury lot meant the inhabitable space would “float” over an unconditioned, partially open space, using either piles or concrete walls. On the flat plain where the Lincoln house sits, rather than go to the expense of digging and building typical concrete foundations and then insulating the floor cavity, we decided to go with a system used often by Maine Passive House designer Chris Corson: a raft slab foundation. In this system, an 8″ concrete slab is poured over a raft of 12″ thick EPS foam. The foam works both as the main floor insulation keeping heat in the house, as well as a blanket to keep the natural heat of the earth under the building, preventing frost from forming that would otherwise affect the integrity of the foundation. The 8″ slab is thick enough that no separate footings are required for structural reasons.
But apart from these differences, the house exhibits the same beauty and efficiency as the one in Middlebury. The various lessons we’ve learned and details we’ve revised from the first house have thus far contributed to a shorter period of construction relative to the first house (helped along by a very light start to winter). With Silver Maple Construction at the helm, we’ll have the quality of construction needed to get this house certified as the next Passive House in Vermont.
Just before Thanksgiving, the Passive House was graced by students from the STEM Academy, part of the Patricia A. Hannaford Career Center in Middlebury, VT. For anyone interested in pursuing careers in engineering and architecture, the opportunity to tour a Passive House is a chance to see the future of building standards in action. The students were guided by lead architect Gregor Masefield, founder of Studio III Architecture, and lead builder Chris North, co-owner of Northern Timbers Construction.
Compared to Europe, where an industry for passive building has been developing since the first Passivhaus was built in Darmstadt, Germany in 1991, passive building in the United States is in its infancy. PHIUS’s database lists about 150 certified projects across the county, with only 5 in Vermont. This house will be the 6th. Meanwhile, passive buildings in Europe number in the tens of thousands. The industry there is so well-established that construction of a passive building in Germany only costs 5-7% more than a regular building, a cost that is more than made up for by energy savings over the life of the building. But even in the US construction costs only run 5-10% more for new buildings, and those costs continue to go down as the industry expands and more people come to recognize the value of the PH standard.
As a consumer, you might think, “Housing is expensive as is. Why should I bother with the higher cost of construction when fuel is so cheap right now?” The price of fuel changes as often as the weather; nothing can guarantee today’s low prices won’t disappear with the next political crisis. But more to the point, we can no longer pretend that our current low standards of building are even remotely sustainable, and it is impossible to ignore the effects of poor construction on the global climate. With the international climate talks beginning today in Paris, the time is ripe for a dramatic shift in the way consumers look at construction.
One day, the Passive House standard will be the minimum requirement for building. The sooner people adopt it not just as a building code, but as a cultural mindset, the better it will be for everyone. We hope the students came away from this tour with some insight into the exciting challenges they’ll encounter.
After the slow but steady pace of the foundation’s construction, the rest of the house seems to spring up while your head is turned. The posts one week, then the floor trusses the next, and most recently the balloon framing and roof trusses. The second floor trusses are next in line and will more fully define the interior space. The rough openings of the windows are already framing beautiful views of the outdoors.
But a good aesthetic is just one of the goals we’re aiming for in building this house. To be certified as a true Passive House, construction is being held to a rigorously high standard. The blue tape is a part of that – it is being used to close every gap between the interior and exterior of the house. By the end of construction, the house will be a sealed bubble with next to no air infiltration.
Winter in Vermont is a beautiful thing, but it doesn’t need to follow you into your home.
A construction site without the construction becomes, simply, a site. But this isn’t just an earthwork sculpture. Lone pipes, cast-in-place sill bolts, and antennae-like structural ties all await their turn in the process. They hint at the even more complex work yet to come.
Construction is in progress at Studio III Architecture’s prototype Passive House! As the foundations get their finishing touches, we reflect on how reality can force upon us design choices we wouldn’t otherwise expect. The original design called for screw pile foundations drilled into the soil as a way to float the main volume above the ground and reduce our carbon footprint by avoiding the use of concrete. Instead, bedrock covers almost all of our buildable area. And so we welcome concrete into our home, whether we want to or not. But at least no one can accuse us of building our house on sand.